Wikipedia:Wikipedia book creator status

Jump to navigation Jump to search

This page provides information about Wikipedia:Books, why the in-house book generator was withdrawn, why template {{Wikipedia books}} was deleted, and what alternatives exists to obtain collections of Wikipedia pages and individual Wikipedia pages.

Background[edit]

The Book namespace with a book creator accompanied with an offline rendering service was introduced in 2009 to generate free collections of Wikipedia articles as e-books. The Wikimedia Foundation turned off the offline rendering service on all Wikimedia wikis in October 2017. Simply put, the offline book generator was no longer maintainable—it frequently broke and had evolving security issues. (see below for alternatives)

Sidebar and template deletion[edit]

Main discussion: Wikipedia:Village pump (proposals)/Archive 177#Deprecate linking to Wikipedia books in templates and articles

In 2019 the book creator link was removed from the sidebar but its user interface remains functional. As it is no longer accompanied by a free book generator, its primary working feature directs users to order a printed copy of a Wikipedia book from PediaPress, a third-party company. Editors in community-wide discussion about removing the book creator and suppressing book templates valued the user experience of Wikipedia readers over the business prospects of third-party companies. The namespace and its transclusions were initially retained in the hope that the WMF would come up with a solution. However in 2021 after years with no prospect of a resolution or funding, the various book templates were removed after a second community-wide discussion with the namespace still retained. Later in 2021, consensus was reached to delete all pages in the book namespace, and WP:REFUND deleted books as requested.

What alternatives are there?[edit]

You can still create and edit a book design using the book creator and upload it to an external rendering service:

  • MediaWiki2LaTeX provides a softcopy PDF service. Uniquely, it remains under active support and may be used online or installed locally. Be aware the computational resources of the server are limited. (Free service)
  • Pedia Press offer final tidying and ordering of print-on-demand bound copies in (approximately) A5 format. (Pay service)
Or
  • For help with downloading a single Wikipedia page as a PDF, see Help:Download as PDF. (Free service)
  • The Wiki-as-Ebook project provides encyclopedias for E-Book-readers created from a large set of Wikipedia articles. (Pay service)

See also[edit]

Information icon.svg Help desk